When you want to invest your retirement funds in alternative assets, such as real estate, private equity, or cryptocurrency, Self-Directed IRAs (SDIRAs) give you that flexibility. Two notable players are IRA Financial and Alto IRA. While both facilitate alternative investing, they have different philosophies, pricing models, strengths, and trade-offs.
Below is a side-by-side comparison across four critical areas: fees & pricing, product options, technology, and reputation & reviews. Use this to see which aligns better with your investing style, comfort level, and goals.
Pricing & Fees: Transparent, Flat, and Investor-Friendly
Fees often determine whether a provider is advantageous for your strategy, especially when you have many transactions or your account grows. Alto IRA adopts a fee structure tied to invested capital (plus transaction/service fees), while IRA Financial is known for its flat-fee model.
 |  | |
Setup Fee | $0 | $0 |
Annual Fee | $495 | $400 |
Asset Value Fee | $0 | $0 |
Investment Fee | $0 | $300 |
Roth Conversion Fee | $0 | $50 |
1 Year Total Cost | $495 | $750 |
5 Year Total Cost | $2,475 | $2,350 |
Based on 4 investments and a $200K balance
IRA Financial:
- Flat, transparent annual fees—Self-Directed IRAs start at $495/year, with other plans available from $100/year.
- No setup fee for a custodian-controlled plan; One-time fee for a Checkbook IRA
- No asset-based fees, transaction fees, or hidden charges—just one clear price.
- IRAfi Crypto platform with low trading costs for buying, selling, and trading crypto directly in the IRA Financial app.
- Ideal for investors holding multiple assets or actively managing deals
Alto IRA:
- Low entry cost, but fees vary by account type (Crypto IRA, Alternative IRA, or IRA via partners)
- Up to $75 investment process fee; no fee when using Alto Marketplace
- Crypto IRA: 1% trade fee + 1% spread (depending on exchange partner)
- Additional partner or custodian fees for certain private investments
- Pay-as-you-go pricing favors occasional or single-asset investors
Summary
IRA Financial’s flat-fee structure offers cost predictability—perfect for investors managing real estate, LLCs, or multiple deals. Alto IRA’s lower entry price appeals to those making infrequent or small investments but can add up quickly for active traders.
Winner: IRA Financial.
Its transparent flat-fee model delivers better long-term value for active investors managing multiple assets.
Winner: IRA Financial.
Its transparent flat-fee model delivers better long-term value for active investors managing multiple assets.
Investment Flexibility & Product Options
When choosing a Self-Directed IRA, flexibility is everything. Both IRA Financial and Alto IRA give investors access to alternative assets—but the range and control differ significantly.
| | |
Self-Directed IRA | ||
Solo 401(k) | ||
Checkbook Control | ||
ROBS Structure | ||
Crypto Platform |
IRA Financial:
- Full investment freedom: real estate, private equity, precious metals, notes, startups, and crypto
- Direct crypto investing through IRA Financial’s integrated platform
- Checkbook IRA and Solo 401(k) options for maximum control
- Supports SEP, SIMPLE, Roth, and Traditional IRAs, plus ROBS for business funding
- No pre-approval needed for most investments under checkbook control
Alto IRA:
- Offers access to private equity, startups, and crypto through approved partners
- Crypto investing supported through Coinbase integration
- No checkbook control option; assets must be custodian-approved
- Account types limited to traditional, Roth, and SEP IRAs
- Best suited for investors who want curated access to specific alternative partners
Summary
IRA Financial provides full control and unlimited investment choices through its LLC or trust structure, making it ideal for hands-on investors. Alto IRA streamlines access to select investments but limits control to pre-approved platforms.
Winner: IRA Financial.
It provides unmatched freedom and flexibility for investors who want full control of their IRA assets.
Winner: IRA Financial.
It provides unmatched freedom and flexibility for investors who want full control of their IRA assets.
Technology: Built for the Modern Investor
Technology defines how easily investors can manage their self-directed accounts. Both IRA Financial and Alto IRA use digital tools to simplify alternative investing, but their approaches reflect different priorities.
IRA Financial:
- Proprietary mobile app for full account management and onboarding
- Integrated dashboard for all investment types, including crypto and real estate
- 100% digital document storage, compliance, and e-signing
- Tech-first approach enables paperless, mobile investing
- Streamlined tools for crypto, transfers, and checkbook control in one place
Alto IRA:
- Clean, user-friendly online platform with guided investment workflows
- Integration with Coinbase for crypto trades
- Easy onboarding for partner-based deals
- No mobile app; desktop-first design
- Relies heavily on third-party integrations rather than in-house technology
Summary
IRA Financial leads in automation and mobile accessibility, giving users complete control from their phone. Alto IRA’s interface is modern and intuitive but limited by its reliance on partners and lack of a native app.
Winner: IRA Financial.
Its mobile-first technology and integrated tools make it the more advanced platform for modern investors.
Winner: IRA Financial.
Its mobile-first technology and integrated tools make it the more advanced platform for modern investors.
Reputation & Customer Reviews: Trusted by Thousands
Reputation can signal reliability, especially when dealing with retirement assets. Both platforms have earned trust, though their audiences differ.
| | |
Trustpilot | 4.8 / 5 | 3.8 / 5 |
4.8 / 5 | N/A | |
Other Platforms | 4.8 / 5 | 3.5 / 5 |
IRA Financial:
- 24,000+ clients across all 50 states
- Backed by 3,000+ 5-star reviews across Google, Trustpilot, and other platforms.
- Founded by tax attorney Adam Bergman, who provides ongoing education through weekly videos and blog content.
- Known for responsive support and educational content
- Occasional feedback mentions learning curve for LLC setups
Alto IRA:
- Founded in 2018, backed by venture capital and partner platforms
- Generally strong user ratings for interface simplicity and customer support
- Recognized for democratizing access to private markets
- Some mixed reviews regarding crypto fees and transaction delays
- Newer company with less institutional history compared to established custodians
Summary
IRA Financial’s longevity and professional expertise make it a trusted choice for investors who value credibility and education. Alto IRA shines with accessibility and modern design but lacks the same depth of experience.
Winner: IRA Financial.
With thousands of satisfied clients and a proven track record, it remains the more trusted and established name in the SDIRA space.
Winner: IRA Financial.
With thousands of satisfied clients and a proven track record, it remains the more trusted and established name in the SDIRA space.
The Bottom Line: Why IRA Financial Is the Smarter Choice
Both IRA Financial and Alto IRA have made alternative investing easier—but they serve different investor types.
Choose IRA Financial if you want:
- Flat, transparent pricing
- Full control through checkbook or trust structures
- A mobile-first, all-in-one platform
- Experience-backed expertise and strong support
Choose Alto IRA if you prefer:
- Low-cost entry and pay-as-you-go pricing
- Simple, guided access to curated private investment partners
- A beginner-friendly platform for smaller or one-off deals
Final Verdict:
For experienced or active investors managing multiple assets, IRA Financial offers unmatched flexibility, transparency, and long-term value. Alto IRA is best for those starting out with smaller amounts or who prefer simplicity—but for depth, control, and credibility, IRA Financial remains the clear winner.
Ready to invest freely and retire confidently?
