What Pearl Jam and Self-Directed IRAs Have in Common

In the late 1980s and early 1990s, alternative rock really was alternative. Bands like Pearl Jam, Nirvana, Soundgarden, and Alice in Chains were considered fringe. They were too raw, too different, and too unconventional for mainstream radio. Airplay was limited, record labels were skeptical, and critics often dismissed them as niche.

Fast forward to today, and it is completely normal to hear The Beatles, The Rolling Stones, Nirvana, and Pearl Jam played back-to-back on the same station. What was once “alternative” is now foundational. Pearl Jam is no longer fringe music. It is mainstream rock.

The same evolution has taken place in retirement investing, especially when it comes to Self-Directed IRAs and alternative investments.

When “Alternative” Really Meant Alternative

Alternative rock challenged the industry’s assumptions. It did not follow traditional formulas, did not fit neatly into existing categories, and was not initially built for mass appeal. Yet it resonated deeply with listeners. Over time, the audience grew, the industry adapted, and the definition of “mainstream” expanded.

That same path of resistance, skepticism, gradual adoption, and eventual acceptance closely mirrors the story of alternative assets inside retirement accounts.

What Is a Self-Directed IRA?

A Self-Directed IRA, often called an SDIRA, is an IRA that allows the account holder to invest in a much broader range of assets than a traditional brokerage IRA. Unlike standard IRAs that are typically limited to publicly traded stocks, bonds, ETFs, and mutual funds, a Self-Directed IRA can invest in:

• Real estate
• Private equity and venture capital
• Hedge funds
• Private businesses
• Promissory notes
• Gold and precious metals
• Cryptocurrency and digital assets

The most important point is this: Self-Directed IRAs are fully legal and have existed since ERISA was enacted in 1974. The U.S. tax code allows IRAs to hold nearly any investment that is not specifically prohibited. The IRS outlines IRA rules, including investments and limitations.

The Original IRA Was Never Meant to Be “Traditional Only”

When Congress created IRAs under ERISA, it did something surprisingly forward-thinking. The Internal Revenue Code does not restrict IRAs to traditional investments. Instead, it allows IRAs to invest in almost any asset unless it is specifically prohibited, such as collectibles or life insurance.

From the very beginning, IRAs were permitted to hold:

• Real estate
• Gold and silver
• Private investments
• Alternative assets

So why did IRAs become synonymous with mutual funds? The answer is simple. Large financial institutions like Fidelity and Schwab built systems designed around public securities. Alternative assets were not excluded by law. They were excluded by infrastructure.

My Own “Pearl Jam Moment” With Self-Directed IRAs

I personally discovered the Self-Directed IRA industry in 2008 while helping a hedge fund client invest IRA funds into a hedge fund.

At the time, I was a tax attorney with a Master’s degree in Taxation, working at some of the largest law firms in the world. I lived inside the Internal Revenue Code, yet I had never heard of Self-Directed IRAs.

That realization stopped me in my tracks.

If I did not know this industry existed, how could the average retirement investor?

When I told my colleagues I was leaving my law firm job to start IRA Financial, they thought I was crazy. They told me:

• “Using IRAs to buy real estate isn’t big enough.”
• “401(k)s are for mutual funds.”
• “Alternative assets don’t belong in retirement accounts.”

But as a lifelong Pearl Jam and alternative rock fan, I had already learned an important lesson. What starts on the fringe does not stay there forever.

Why Investors Are Moving Alternative Assets into Retirement Accounts

Over the past decade, millions of Americans have started using IRAs and 401(k)s to invest in alternative assets. Why?

1. Diversification
   Public markets have become increasingly correlated. Alternative assets can provide diversification beyond stocks and bonds.
2. Inflation Protection
   Assets like real estate, private businesses, and commodities have historically served as hedges against inflation.
3. Control and Knowledge
   Many investors understand real estate, private companies, or similar industries better than they understand public markets. A Self-Directed IRA allows them to invest in what they know.
4. Tax Advantages
   Self-Directed IRAs retain all traditional IRA tax benefits:

• Tax-deferred growth in a Traditional SDIRA
• Tax-free growth in a Roth SDIRA

Rental income, private equity gains, and crypto appreciation can grow without current taxation.

What Alternative Investments Can You Hold in a Self-Directed IRA?

Most assets are permitted unless they are specifically prohibited. Common SDIRA investments include:

• Real estate, including residential, commercial, and raw land
• Private equity and venture capital funds
• Hedge funds
• Private business stock
• Cryptocurrency
• Gold and precious metals
• Private notes and lending

The risk lies in the investment itself, not in the Self-Directed IRA structure.

Institutional Validation: Alternative Assets Go Mainstream

The mainstream acceptance of alternative investments is no longer theoretical. Larry Fink, CEO of BlackRock, the world’s largest asset manager, has publicly stated that investors should consider allocating a meaningful portion of their portfolios to alternative assets to improve diversification and long-term outcomes.

BlackRock’s actions support this view. The firm has significantly expanded into private equity, private credit, infrastructure, and real assets. When the world’s largest asset manager embraces alternatives, they are no longer truly alternative.

Regulatory Momentum: The 2025 Executive Order on Alternatives

In August 2025, President Donald Trump signed an executive order directing the Department of Labor to modernize fiduciary guidance around alternative investments in 401(k) plans. The goals included:

• Reducing fiduciary uncertainty
• Expanding access to private markets
• Modernizing retirement investing
• Encouraging responsible inclusion of alternative assets

For years, plan fiduciaries avoided alternatives not because they were illegal, but because the guidance felt unclear. That uncertainty is now beginning to fade.

The Power of a Self-Directed IRA

A Self-Directed IRA gives investors:

• Broader investment choice
• Tax-advantaged growth
• True diversification
• Inflation protection
• Greater control over retirement capital

This is not about speculation. It is about alignment.

From Alternative to Mainstream

Today, Self-Directed IRAs are no longer niche. Millions of Americans use them to invest in real estate, private funds, gold, and digital assets. Financial institutions, regulators, and asset managers increasingly recognize that alternative assets are not optional. They are essential.

Just like Pearl Jam.

Once dismissed as alternative, Pearl Jam is now classic rock. Played alongside the Beatles and the Rolling Stones, studied, respected, and enduring.

The Bottom Line

Self-Directed IRAs did not suddenly become legal. They were always legal. They became understood. And just as alternative rock reshaped music by expanding what belonged on the radio, Self-Directed IRAs are reshaping retirement investing by expanding what belongs in a portfolio. Alternative assets are no longer alternative. They are mainstream.

FAQ: Self-Directed IRAs and Alternative Investments

Are Self-Directed IRAs legal?
Yes. They have existed since ERISA was enacted in 1974 and are fully permitted under the Internal Revenue Code.

Why don’t most banks offer Self-Directed IRAs?
Traditional custodians focus on public securities and often lack the infrastructure needed to custody alternative assets.

Are Self-Directed IRAs risky?
The risk comes from the investment itself, not the IRA structure. Proper compliance and due diligence are essential.

---