The Rise of Progressive Politics and the Roth IRA: Why Locking In Tax-Free Wealth Matters More Than Ever
If there is one lesson I have learned during more than two decades practicing tax law, it is this: tax laws never stand still.
Congress changes.
Presidents change.
Political priorities evolve.
The economy expands and contracts.
Government spending rises and falls.
Through all of these changes, one constant remains: the federal government always needs revenue.
As Americans, we naturally spend a great deal of time thinking about how to grow our wealth. We focus on finding better investments, earning higher returns, buying real estate, investing in stocks, or even launching our own businesses. Yet many investors spend surprisingly little time thinking about what may ultimately be the largest expense they will ever face: taxes.
The truth is that building wealth is only half the battle. Keeping it may prove even more important.
That is precisely why I believe the Roth IRA has become one of the most valuable retirement planning tools ever created by Congress. In my opinion, its value is only increasing as the United States enters an era of greater political uncertainty, mounting government debt, and growing pressure for higher taxes.
No one knows exactly what tax rates will look like ten or twenty years from now. Anyone who tells you otherwise is simply guessing. However, history provides valuable clues, and today’s political environment suggests that higher taxes, particularly on higher-income Americans, are no longer merely an academic discussion. They have become a central part of our national political debate.
From my perspective as a tax lawyer, this makes one thing abundantly clear: locking in tax-free retirement wealth today may be one of the smartest financial decisions an American can make.
Key Takeaways
- Today’s federal income tax rates are historically low. The top marginal rate has exceeded 90% for much of the twentieth century. Assuming rates will stay where they are today is a significant bet.
- A Roth IRA allows you to pay tax once, under today’s rules, and potentially never pay federal income tax again on decades of investment growth. That advantage becomes even more powerful if future tax rates rise.
- Unlike a Traditional IRA, a Roth IRA has no Required Minimum Distributions during your lifetime, giving you complete control over when and whether you access your money in retirement.
- A Self-Directed Roth IRA combines tax-free growth with investment flexibility, allowing you to hold real estate, private equity, cryptocurrency, private lending, and other alternative assets alongside the same powerful tax advantages.
- Roth conversions have no income limits. Any investor, regardless of income, can generally convert eligible retirement assets to a Roth IRA and lock in today’s tax rates on future growth.
Politics Matter Because Tax Policy Matters
Whether you consider yourself a Republican, Democrat, Independent, or politically unaffiliated, it is impossible to ignore how dramatically America’s political conversation has changed over the past decade.
Within the Democratic Party, the progressive movement has become increasingly influential. Politicians have advocated for policies that envision a significantly larger role for government, including expanded healthcare programs, affordable housing initiatives, tuition assistance, climate-related investments, expanded child tax credits, wealth taxes, higher corporate taxes, and higher tax rates on upper-income Americans.
Reasonable people can disagree about whether these policies are good or bad. My purpose is not to argue politics. My purpose is to discuss taxes.
Every government program has one unavoidable reality: it must be financed. Governments can borrow money for a period of time, but debt eventually must be serviced. Governments can issue additional debt, but interest costs continue to rise. Governments can reduce spending, but that often proves politically difficult. Ultimately, there are only a handful of ways to pay for larger government, and taxation remains the most significant.
Even outside progressive policy proposals, the United States faces enormous fiscal challenges. Our population is aging. Millions of Americans are entering retirement. Social Security and Medicare obligations continue to grow. Interest payments on the national debt now consume hundreds of billions of dollars annually. Defense spending remains substantial. Infrastructure requires investment. These financial obligations exist regardless of which political party controls Congress or occupies the White House.
As a result, the long-term conversation increasingly centers on one unavoidable question: where will the revenue come from?
That question should matter to every retirement investor.
History Shows Today’s Tax Rates Are Actually Quite Low
One of the biggest misconceptions I encounter is that Americans believe today’s income tax rates are historically high. They’re not.
When viewed over the past century, today’s federal income tax rates are relatively modest. The modern federal income tax began with the ratification of the Sixteenth Amendment in 1913. At that time, the highest federal income tax rate was only 7%.
That quickly changed. As America entered World War I, tax rates rose dramatically. During the Great Depression, rates increased again. By 1944, the highest federal income tax rate reached an astonishing 94%. Throughout much of the 1950s, the highest rate exceeded 90%. During the 1960s and much of the 1970s, it remained around 70%.
Today’s investors often assume that a top federal rate of 37% is exceptionally burdensome. Historically speaking, it is less than half of what many Americans paid for much of the twentieth century.
| Period | Top Federal Income Tax Rate | Historical Context |
|---|---|---|
| 1913 | 7% | Federal income tax introduced after the Sixteenth Amendment |
| 1917 | 67% | Increased to help finance World War I |
| 1918–1921 | 77% | Continued wartime financing |
| 1925–1931 | 25% | Tax reductions during the Roaring Twenties |
| 1932–1935 | 63% | Increased during the Great Depression |
| 1936–1940 | 79% | Expansion of New Deal-era taxation |
| 1942–1943 | 88% | World War II financing |
| 1944 | 94% | Highest top marginal income tax rate in U.S. history |
| 1945–1963 | 91% | Post-war America maintained very high tax rates |
| 1965–1981 | 70% | Top rate remained at 70% for much of the 1960s and 1970s |
| 1982–1986 | 50% | Major tax reductions during the Reagan administration |
| 1987 | 38.5% | Continued tax reform |
| 1988–1990 | 28–33% | Lowest modern top rates following the Tax Reform Act of 1986 |
| 1993–2000 | 39.6% | Rates increased during the Clinton administration |
| 2003–2012 | 35% | Reduced under the Bush tax cuts |
| 2013–2017 | 39.6% | Returned to pre-2003 level |
| 2018–Present | 37% | Reduced under the Tax Cuts and Jobs Act |
For much of the twentieth century, the highest federal income tax rate ranged from 70% to more than 90%. The United States maintained a top marginal rate above 90% for nearly two decades following World War II. While history never guarantees the future, it clearly demonstrates that tax rates can and often do change dramatically over time.
America Is Still One of the Lower-Taxed Developed Economies
Many Americans believe they already pay the highest taxes in the world. The data tells a more nuanced story.
Compared to many advanced democracies, including Canada, Germany, France, the United Kingdom, Sweden, and Denmark, the United States generally imposes lower top marginal income tax rates and a lower overall tax burden as a percentage of economic output. Many of these countries also rely heavily on value-added taxes that generate significant government revenue in addition to income taxes.
This is not an argument that one system is better than another. The important point is that the United States is not an outlier with unusually high taxation. In many respects, it remains a relatively low-tax nation compared with its developed peers.
If history is any guide, and if America’s long-term fiscal obligations continue to grow, there is a reasonable possibility that future policymakers could look to higher-income taxpayers for additional revenue. Investors who have built substantial Roth assets may find themselves in a far stronger position than those who accumulated all of their retirement savings in traditional, taxable retirement accounts.
Why the Roth IRA May Be the Greatest Tax Benefit Congress Ever Created
As a tax lawyer, I have spent my entire career studying the Internal Revenue Code and helping individuals legally minimize taxes while building long-term wealth. Few provisions are as powerful or as straightforward as the Roth IRA.
The Roth IRA allows you to pay tax once, under today’s tax rules, and potentially never pay federal income tax again on decades of investment growth. That is an extraordinary benefit, especially if you believe tax rates may be higher in the future.
When most people think about retirement planning, they focus on accumulating the largest account balance possible. Sophisticated tax planning requires asking a different question: how much of that money will actually belong to me after taxes?
There is a significant difference between having $2 million in a Traditional IRA and $2 million in a Roth IRA. The balances may look identical on paper, but they are not economically equivalent.
Money inside a Traditional IRA has generally never been taxed. Every dollar you withdraw in retirement is subject to ordinary income tax. If tax rates rise between now and retirement, you could ultimately pay substantially more than you expected.
Money inside a qualified Roth IRA is fundamentally different. Assuming you satisfy the applicable rules, every dollar you withdraw, including all investment appreciation, can generally be distributed completely free from federal income tax.
That distinction becomes even more valuable if future tax rates increase.
Traditional IRA vs. Roth IRA
A Traditional IRA generally provides an upfront tax benefit. Your contribution may be deductible, reducing your taxable income today and deferring tax until retirement.
A Roth IRA works in exactly the opposite manner. There is no current income tax deduction. You contribute after-tax dollars. The reward comes later: once the account satisfies the qualification requirements, all future earnings and qualified distributions are generally tax-free.
Think of it this way. With a Traditional IRA, the government becomes your future retirement partner because it has a claim on every dollar you eventually withdraw. With a Roth IRA, once you have paid the tax upfront, future qualified appreciation generally belongs entirely to you.
As someone who has practiced tax law for decades, I prefer certainty whenever possible. The Roth IRA provides exactly that. Rather than worrying about what Congress may do ten, twenty, or thirty years from now, you have already settled your tax obligation under today’s law.
The 2026 Roth IRA Rules
For 2026, eligible individuals may contribute up to $7,500 to a Roth IRA. Individuals age 50 or older may contribute an additional catch-up amount, bringing the maximum annual contribution to $8,600.
Direct Roth IRA contributions are subject to income limitations, meaning higher-income taxpayers may not qualify to contribute directly. Fortunately, many higher-income individuals can still build Roth assets through a Backdoor Roth IRA or a Roth conversion.
To receive completely tax-free treatment on investment earnings, two requirements generally must be satisfied. First, the Roth IRA must have been open for at least five years. Second, the distribution generally must occur after the account owner reaches age 59½, or another qualifying exception applies.
Once both requirements are satisfied, every dollar of appreciation inside the account, from dividends and interest to stock gains, real estate appreciation, cryptocurrency gains, private equity profits, and business sale proceeds, may generally be distributed completely free from federal income tax.
The Hidden Advantage Most Investors Overlook: No Required Minimum Distributions
Traditional IRAs generally require Required Minimum Distributions (RMDs) beginning at age 73. Congress essentially tells you when you must begin taking money out of your account. Those distributions are generally taxable, even if you do not need the money, even if you would rather leave the assets invested, even if withdrawing pushes you into a higher tax bracket.
The Roth IRA is different. During your lifetime, there are generally no RMDs. Your investments can continue growing tax-free for as long as you live.
This flexibility becomes even more valuable if tax rates rise later in retirement. Rather than being forced to recognize taxable income on the government’s timeline, Roth IRA owners generally decide if and when they wish to access their money.
The Power of Tax-Free Compounding
Compounding allows investment earnings to generate additional earnings year after year. The longer the investment horizon, the more dramatic the results.
Suppose a 30-year-old contributes $7,500 annually to a Roth IRA for 35 years and earns an average annual return of 8%. By age 65, the account could potentially grow to well over $1.2 million, despite total contributions of only about $262,500. More than $900,000 of that value could represent investment appreciation, all of which may generally be withdrawn completely tax-free inside a qualified Roth IRA.
Compare that with a Traditional IRA. While investment growth is tax-deferred, every dollar distributed in retirement generally becomes taxable as ordinary income. If future tax rates are higher than today’s, the after-tax value could be substantially lower than many investors expect.
The true value of a Roth IRA cannot be measured simply by today’s tax deduction. Its real value lies in eliminating decades of future taxation on investment growth.
Why a Self-Directed Roth IRA May Be the Ultimate Wealth-Building Tool
Everything discussed so far applies to every Roth IRA. But as someone who has spent a career helping Americans invest beyond Wall Street, I believe the true power of the Roth IRA is unlocked when combined with a Self-Directed Roth IRA.
A Self-Directed Roth IRA follows the exact same tax rules as any other Roth IRA. The difference is investment flexibility. Instead of being limited to the menu offered by a brokerage firm, a Self-Directed Roth IRA allows investors to hold real estate, private equity, venture capital, private businesses, startup companies, cryptocurrency, precious metals, private lending, tax liens, limited partnerships, and many other alternative investments permitted under the Internal Revenue Code.
As a tax lawyer, I often ask clients a simple question: where would you rather earn your biggest investment gains, inside a taxable account or inside a Roth IRA? For most investors, the answer is obvious. The assets with the greatest appreciation potential generally belong inside the account that offers the greatest tax benefits.
Consider purchasing investment real estate inside a Self-Directed Roth IRA for $250,000. Over twenty years, the property appreciates to $1.2 million while generating rental income that remains inside the account. Assuming the investment complies with IRA rules and the owner satisfies Roth qualification requirements, both the appreciation and accumulated earnings may generally be distributed free from federal income tax.
Or consider a startup investment. An investor contributes $50,000 from a Self-Directed Roth IRA to acquire shares in a young private business. Fifteen years later, the company is acquired for $5 million. In a taxable account, that sale could produce a significant capital gains liability. Inside a qualified Self-Directed Roth IRA, the gain may generally escape federal income taxation altogether.
That is why I tell clients that a Roth IRA should not simply hold your safest investments. It should hold your investments with the greatest long-term appreciation potential.
If you want to explore how a Self-Directed Roth IRA could work for your investment strategy, IRA Financial’s team of in-house tax specialists is available for a free consultation. We help investors understand what is actually possible inside a retirement account and how to structure investments to maximize long-term tax-free growth.
Book a free call with a self-directed retirement specialist
- Review your self-directed retirement options
- Learn about investing in alternative assets
- Get all of your questions answered
Three Ways to Build Roth Wealth
Many investors believe they missed their opportunity to build a Roth IRA because their income is too high or because they already accumulated substantial savings in Traditional IRAs or 401(k) plans. That is usually not the case.
Annual Roth IRA contributions. Subject to applicable income limitations, eligible taxpayers can contribute each year and gradually build tax-free retirement savings over time.
Rollover from a Roth 401(k). After leaving an employer or becoming eligible for a distribution, assets from a Roth 401(k) can generally be rolled into a Roth IRA without current taxation.
Roth conversion. A Roth conversion allows you to move assets from a Traditional IRA or other eligible pre-tax retirement account into a Roth IRA. Unlike annual contributions, there are no income limits on conversions. Whether you earn $75,000 or $7.5 million annually, you generally have the ability to convert eligible retirement assets to a Roth IRA.
The tradeoff is that the amount converted is generally included in taxable income for the year of conversion. That tax bill can be substantial. But once paid, future qualified growth inside the Roth IRA may never be taxed again. A Roth conversion is ultimately a calculated decision to pay tax under today’s rates rather than exposing future investment growth to whatever rates Congress may establish years from now.
Should You Convert?
There is no universal answer. Anyone who tells you every investor should complete a Roth conversion, or that no one should, is oversimplifying an inherently personal decision.
Instead, consider these questions:
Can you comfortably pay the conversion tax using money outside your retirement account?
How many years remain before retirement?
Do you expect your investments to appreciate significantly?
Do you believe your tax rate in retirement may be higher than today?
Do you anticipate leaving Roth assets to your heirs?
Do you believe federal income tax rates may rise over the next decade?
The more often you answer yes, the stronger the case for considering a conversion.
‘Every investor’s situation is different, which is why Roth conversions should always be evaluated within the context of a comprehensive tax strategy.
Final Thoughts
Tax laws never remain the same. Congress changes, political priorities shift, and tax rates rise and fall. While no one can predict exactly what future tax policy will look like, history tells us that today’s rates are relatively low by historical standards. The growing national debt, expanding government spending, and changing political landscape could all put upward pressure on taxes in the years ahead.
The Roth IRA has never been more valuable. By paying tax under today’s rules, you have the opportunity to build decades of tax-free growth without worrying about future income tax rates. For investors seeking even greater long-term growth potential, a Self-Directed Roth IRA can be especially powerful, combining tax-free benefits with the full range of alternative asset investments the IRS permits.
You cannot control future tax laws. But you can control how you prepare for them. In retirement, it is not just about how much you accumulate. It is about how much you get to keep.
Adam Bergman is a tax attorney and the founder of IRA Financial, one of the largest Self-Directed IRA platforms in the United States. He has helped more than 27,000 clients take control of their retirement savings, overseeing over $7 billion in retirement assets. Adam is also the author of nine books focused on helping investors understand and confidently manage their retirement strategies.
Related Articles
July 3, 2026
Self-Directed IRA Fee Structures: How Flat Fee and Asset-Based Models Compare Over Time
Most Self-Directed IRA investors compare custodians by looking at the annual fee headline number. That comparison is almost always misleading. A…
July 2, 2026
AI, the S&P 500, and the Self-Directed IRA: Why Diversification Matters More Than Ever
If you are a Self-Directed IRA investor or anyone building long-term retirement wealth, the rise of artificial intelligence raises a question most…
June 27, 2026
The Death of the Bogle Model: Why Today’s Retirement Investors Need More Than Index Funds
For a generation of Americans, the Boglehead playbook was gospel. Put 60% of your retirement savings into a broad S&P 500 index fund, put 40%…
June 22, 2026
Buy a Home in Your Self-Directed Roth IRA and Live in It Tax-Free
Most investors understand that a Roth IRA offers tax-free growth and tax-free withdrawals. What many people don't realize is that a Roth IRA can do…




