For investors who want more control over their retirement savings, a Self-Directed IRA (SDIRA) makes it possible to go beyond Wall Street and invest in alternative assets such as real estate, private lending, startups, precious metals, and cryptocurrency. Two well-known providers in this space are IRA Financial and Broad Financial. Both offer Checkbook Control and Solo 401(k) plans, but their approaches differ, especially in fees, technology, and breadth of services. Broad Financial works in partnership with its sister company, Madison Trust, for custody and administration.

This comparison walks through pricing, investment options, technology, and reputation.

Pricing & Fees: Transparent, Flat, and Investor-Friendly

Note: this table compares the Checkbook IRA (IRA LLC) offering of both companies, since that is Broad Financial’s core product.

Pricing pulled from company website, as of the article publish date, and based on a $200,000 account balance.

IRA Financial:

• Checkbook IRA setup fee of $999, then a flat $495/year with no transaction or asset value fees.
• No asset-based fees or per-transaction charges beyond the setup and annual fee.
• Integrated crypto investing with low trading costs inside the IRA Financial app.

Broad Financial:

• $1,145 one-time fee to establish the IRA LLC or IRA Trust, plus a separate $125 setup fee to Madison Trust as custodian.
• $556/year custodial fee, billed quarterly at $139, fixed regardless of account size or number of assets held.
• $100 fee if you convert or recharacterize a Roth IRA.
• Solo 401(k) plans carry a separate $995 setup fee plus a $149 annual compliance fee, not the IRA LLC/Trust custodial fee above.

Summary

Broad Financial’s setup costs more upfront than IRA Financial’s Checkbook IRA, but its flat $556/year custodial fee doesn’t rise as you add more assets, unlike Madison Trust’s direct per-asset pricing. Over 5 years, the gap between the two providers narrows to less than the cost of a single transaction.

Product & Service Offerings: Focused vs. Full-Service

Choosing the right custodian depends on the types of investments you want to make and the level of support you need. IRA Financial and Broad Financial both give investors checkbook control, but Broad Financial’s offering stays narrower and is built exclusively around checkbook structures.

IRA Financial:

• Full range of traditional SDIRA investments plus direct crypto investing through IRAfi Crypto, all inside one account.
• Offers both a standard custodian-directed Self-Directed IRA and a Checkbook IRA, so investors can choose the structure that fits their needs.
• Stock, ETF, bond, and options trading through Interactive Brokers, available as a $100/year add-on.
• Advanced structures including Solo 401(k), SEP and SIMPLE IRAs, HSA and Coverdell accounts, and ROBS for business funding.
• IRA Compliance Shield ($299/year): in-house audit protection, tax consultation, and prohibited transaction pre-clearance.

Broad Financial:

• Specializes exclusively in checkbook-control structures: IRA LLC, IRA Trust, and Solo 401(k), with no standard custodian-directed SDIRA option.
• Supports real estate, private lending, precious metals, tax liens, startups, and crypto through an LLC structure.
• Crypto access through CryptoFlex IRA requires a dedicated LLC and an external Titan Bank checking account.
• No HSA, Coverdell, or ROBS structures.
• Relies on Madison Trust for custody, recordkeeping, and compliance rather than offering it in-house.

Summary

Broad Financial’s entire model is built around checkbook control, so investors who want that structure exclusively get a provider focused on doing it well. But there’s no option to start with a simpler custodian-directed SDIRA and add checkbook control later, or vice versa. IRA Financial offers both structures side by side, plus a broader set of account types, integrated crypto trading, and in-house compliance support.

Technology: Built for the Modern Investor

Technology plays a growing role in managing retirement accounts, especially for investors who want real-time visibility. IRA Financial has built a mobile-first platform, while Broad Financial relies on web-based forms and its sister company’s custodian portal.

IRA Financial:

• Newly-updated mobile app and account dashboard with clean UI/UX and modern functionality.
• Offers a fully digital on-boarding experience, automated compliance, and secure document storage.
• In-house crypto trading, real-time dashboards, and checkbook control in a single portal.

Broad Financial:

• Web-based forms and account setup through downloadable documents.
• No proprietary mobile app or live investor dashboard.
• Transactions and account management run through Madison Trust’s custodian portal or manual communication.

Summary

Broad Financial leans on personalized onboarding and its custodian partner’s portal rather than its own digital tools. IRA Financial keeps every feature, from real-time dashboards to crypto trading, under a single login.

Reputation & Customer Reviews: Trusted by Thousands

Reputation matters when trusting a provider with your retirement assets. Both IRA Financial and Broad Financial have built track records in the self-directed space.

IRA Financial:

• Strong reputation for fast account setup, responsive customer service, and straightforward pricing.
• Over 3,000 5-star reviews across Google, Trustpilot, and other platforms.
• Founded by tax attorney Adam Bergman, who educates investors via weekly videos, podcasts, and blog articles.

Broad Financial:

• Strong Google rating with a large review volume, with clients praising responsive support.
• A+ BBB rating since 2014.
• Small sample size on Trustpilot, so its high rating carries less weight than a larger platform.

Summary

Broad Financial’s Google reviews reflect a genuinely well-regarded support team at scale. IRA Financial’s advantage comes from a strong, consistent presence across multiple major platforms rather than concentrated on one.

---

The Bottom Line: Why IRA Financial Is the Smarter Choice

Both IRA Financial and Broad Financial give investors checkbook control over their retirement funds, and Broad Financial’s focused approach and personalized onboarding are real strengths for investors who want exactly that. But for someone who wants the flexibility to choose between a standard SDIRA or a Checkbook IRA, a broader set of account types, and in-house compliance support, IRA Financial offers more.

Whether you’re looking to invest in real estate, trade crypto, or fund a new business with your retirement account, IRA Financial is designed to support every part of your retirement strategy, efficiently, affordably, and under one roof.